Battle of Sugars: Sucrose versus corn syrup

Phil Owen | June 01, 2012

Fit for the Road

Is high fructose corn syrup worse for you than sugar?

By Phil Owen

There is an ongoing debate in our society about which is healthier for you: good old-fashioned sucrose, otherwise known as sugar, or high fructose corn syrup.

Not many people believe high fructose corn syrup is healthier, as the debate typically centers on whether the advent of the substance as a sweetener in the United States is to blame for the obesity epidemic.

“It’s prudent to consume any added sugar only in moderation.”

— Jennifer K. Nelson,

Mayo Clinic nutritionist

High fructose corn syrup is the most-used sweetener in beverages and sweetened foods in the US due to government subsidies of the corn industry and quotas and import tariffs on sucrose; generally speaking, you can’t turn around in a grocery store without hitting something sweetened with high fructose corn syrup.

There have not been that many long-term studies on the effect of high fructose corn syrup on the body, though, so conclusive evidence that it isn’t good for you is lacking. A 2007 study by the Center for Food, Nutrition, and Agriculture Policy at the University of Maryland sums up the problem as such: “While it appears likely that the biological effects of HFCS and sucrose are similar, it is premature to conclude whether or not there are any differences in the mechanisms by which sucrose and HFCS are metabolized in the absence of this important research.” Also, there has been little in the way of government-funded research on the matter.

There is one study, though, conducted at Princeton University in 2010, that claims to conclusively link HFCS with obesity. In the study, they gave rats water sweetened with either HFCS or sugar, and those who consumed the HFCS gained significantly more weight.

Fundamentally, the two substances are similar; table sugar is 50 percent glucose and 50 percent fructose, while most HFCS is roughly 55 percent fructose, 42 percent glucose and 3 percent saccharides. Where they differ is in how they are combined. In sugar, the glucose and fructose are chemically bound to each other, whereas in HFCS they are not. Because of that difference, they are digested in different ways, but it is unknown exactly how.

Mayo Clinic nutritionist Jennifer K. Nelson says since we don’t know for sure what effects HFCS has on the body, it is better to simply avoid anything that has sugar added, because both sugar and HFCS add calories to what you’re consuming. The general wisdom is that if you consume more energy than you need, you will gain weight. A good rule of thumb: Avoid overconsumption of both sugars. On the road, stick to diet drinks or water, as beverages are where you’ll find the most high fructose corn syrup per serving.

Artificial no-energy sweeteners such as aspartame and Splenda are considered safe, and the concerns that aspartame may cause cancer in humans have been generally disproven.

 

QUICK FACTS

Reducing sugar/HFCS intake

• Choose water over sodas, or include the occasional diet soft drink.

• Look for “no sugar added” on juice labels.

• When available, pick fresh fruit; or pre-cut fruit, or canned fruit kept in fruit juices (not syrups).

• Read food nutrition labels.

These will give you the best indication of what you’re eating and drinking.

More About:

OverdriveOnline.com strives to maintain an open forum for reader opinions. Click here to read our comment policy.