Panel highlights CSA data-quality issues

| February 05, 2013
  • Tom

    The whole scoring system is totalty off center ,what about a little oil drip a wire hanging All points added to your score. next thing you know your score goes up, then your INS. goes up,why are they not addressing the small violations for the points they give out?

  • Ray O

    Another part of the problem is shown in this quote from an industry professional, from the article

    “I’ve got shippers who are eliminating carriers from consideration whose
    relative score [is as low as] 40-50 percent” in one or more Behavioral
    Analysis and Safety Improvement Category.”

    What people see is PERCENTAGE … however aren’t all scores based on PERCENTILE which statistically is entirely different. I have seen this mistake constantly since the inception of this program of scoring.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1269137418 Mike Jones

    The SHIPPERS are half the problem…the Heat should be on them to get in the Real World and stop causing accidents with their retarded operations.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1269137418 Mike Jones

    These shippers AND Broker/ “logistics companies are hiring any illegal immigrunt they can find with beat old trucks to RACE down the highways as fast as they can go..working for Lowest Rates possible…….nobody mentions THAT at these stupid “meetings”…..what a sickening joke.

  • Bryan Pierce

    This system is putting a lot of good people and O/O out of business while they are trying to work out the bugs. This really disheartening they can cause damage and not be held accountable for it.

  • Dave

    Illegals with beat up trucks? Where do you live. Our country is catering to the non-american. Giving them money for companies and new equipment. This has been coming. Its part of something to knockout all of us little business owners. Just like the price of fuel. Theirs know reason it should be hire than gas. Its a recycled product. They just keep on coming up with more crap to sideline us(o/o). Your right. Everything is part of that score.Which is B/S.Things happen without you knowing.And petty stuff.

  • Andrea Sitler

    CSA was created with good intentions, as are most government programs but again, as most, they go awry. Until data quality is improved, the results need to be kept private. It just like the tests at school for the state; children are graded by percentile and not grades (e.g. A, B,C). This is confusing to most parents as this grading system is to the public. People see 40 and 50 and immediately think failing/failure. While, in this case, 90% is failure, I bet many would see that as an “A” that do not understand the system. Therein lies the issues, we have users with no understanding of what they are reading. The data is poorly gathered and the reporting method needs improvement. Until both are done it just unfair showing this “junk” data to the public especially when the uninformed general public are using this a grading scale. It is unjustly costing companies and O/Os loads. Is the gov going to be responsible for the lost income due to their negligent reporting system? I think not.

  • Albert

    What I don’t understand is how my company gets compared to a company that has fatalities. I make sure not to hire unsafe drivers, I personally road test and address unsafe habits before something bad happens yet I can get a bad score for bad tires while someone with 2000 trucks and a couple fatalities has a good score.

    I don’t think that the rating system is fair especially when you compare “vehicle maintenance” compared to “percentage of revenue” between a large company and a 5 truck company. While a large company cost is less than 1 percent a small company can easily pay over 5 percent of revenue. Especially today when taxes are out of this world and if you have a yard big enough to have a garage for maintenance you will be taxed out of existence unless you get into the truck repair business and bring in outside work which is not what a trucking company is.

  • Wayne Yoder

    If the FMCSA has determined they can’t determine cause from a police accident report, wouldn’t that put to question the validity of any police report? I personally in the last week have received 2 inspections from 1 state where a wrong statute was referenced.
    Does it make sense that a carrier can go from a 62% ranking to an 81% ranking even though their measure did not change, simply because they had 1 more inspection with a violation that pushed them into a different carrier group?
    Why rank carriers against carriers? Why not factor the number of good vs. bad inspections into the measure and determine a deficient cutoff in each basic?

  • http://www.facebook.com/ed.slattery.9 Ed Slattery

    My wife was killed and two sons seriously injured, one permanently, when a trucker fell asleep at the wheel while driving a triple tractor trailer in Ohio. All this quibbling about scores is disgusting. What industry would accept 3500 or more deaths a year besides the trucking industry? There not all your fault for sure but why don’t we have a zero accident goal that we take seriously. I for one would endorse massive public service announcements, primarily on radio, about driving safely, especially around 80,000 pound vehicles but the industry has to take responsibility for the deaths and injuries that you cause by your actions or inactions. I am not anti trucker or trucking industry but am anti selfish, profit motivated greed that treats lives and injuries as a cost of doing business.

  • J Brown

    I’m right along side of you on that one, I’m all for safety, but this business of trying to put a fellow out of business for pittly things like a little oil leak, or hole in the mudflap, or even a logbook being a few hours behind is getting rediculous, The bad roads caused a break in a wire to the turn signal light on the trailer. Got a DOT inspection in a scale in GA, and I asked if I could check it out to see what was wrong with it, and they still gave me an out of service. I’m ready for the Lord to take me out of this cruel, unforgiving , unmerciful world

  • Lady Trucker

    I’m an o/o who has NEVER had an accident of any kind. Never had a ticket of any kind other than DOT, and non of which were for any thing that could have resulted in an accident. Yet if you look at my score one could conclude that I’m a danger to myself and others. The smaller your company the more your picked on. I’m stopped as much as 2 times a week for BS. My truck is older but well kept. I have repairs bills to prove this. I see big names rolling down the highway with headlights and tail lights burned out, driving with blown tires, which can be seen from a distance by any law enforcement officer and yet nothing is said. I how ever received a ticket for a burned out lic plate light in the middle of the day. I was stopped in AL and received a DOT ticket for Form and Matter… officer said my 3’s looked like 5’s and he did not want to accept my logs as they were filled out. Discounting the fact that I had BOL and fuel tickets to back the logs up.

    I believe the system was designed to take out the o/o of this country and let the big guys get bigger. They hire non English speaking drivers who drive like bats out of hell. And help me understand this “If he can’t speak a word of English how does he read road signs or maps or BOL??? Let’s get real. If a driver has no accidents, and no traffic tickets of any kind ever, at the age of 52, then that truck and driver should be considered safe in my book.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1269137418 Mike Jones

    Yea..more “data” while thousands of ILLEGAL ALIENS drive thru your weigh stations DAILY…..keeping those Freight Rates DOWN for the Rich corporations….these cops Tie Up the American Trucker compiling “data” while the Illegals haul cheap freight everywhere Unquestioned!!!! You ANT question them because they DONT SPEAK or UNDERSTAND English….this whole program is a smoke screen to drive the Americans OUT of trucking like they did in the Construction Trade.

  • Pingback: Failure of CSA illustrated in the records of applicants to the Cross Border Pilot Program with Mexico

OverdriveOnline.com strives to maintain an open forum for reader opinions. Click here to read our comment policy.