Should enforcers focus more on traffic violations? FMCSA rep, CSA critic spar over program

| November 13, 2013

inspection csaOutspoken CSA critic and data showman Steve Bryan — head of Vigillo, a data company that helps fleets adjust their CSA scores —  squared off on the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s Compliance, Safety, Accountability program at the American Trucking Associations Management Conference & Exhibition in Orlando, Fla., last month, per his usual routine.

Bryan tossed out data backing up the oft-derided state-to-state disparity in enforcement and reporting, along with overwhelming tilt of violations that come in the Vehicle Maintenance BASIC, which makes up 80 percent of all violations written.


Carriers, drivers aligned on need for shift in enforcement priorities

Following a speech at the 2013 CVSA spring workshop which decried states' outsize inspection focus, Overdrive readers responded largely positively to a message of new ...

He then made his way to this point: Why does maintenance receive so much focus? Isn’t it common sense that traffic enforcement — like speeding violations — would more obviously target crash risk?

Overdrive Senior Editor Kevin Jones has a full write-up on the panel discussion on OD sister site CCJ, where Jones writes about the sparring match that took place between Bryan and FMCSA’s Bill Quade,  the agency’s associate administrator for enforcement.

Quade countered Bryan’s pointed attack on CSA’s data problem by saying “Data can be dangerous.”

Quade also said that there are about 10,000 enforcers who know how to inspect a truck in the U.S., while there are about 500,000 cops and enforcers who pull vehicles over for speeding tickets — his point being that truck inspectors should be inspecting trucks, not concentrating on traffic violations.  


Crashes and interventions: The fault handicap

FMCSA may be a long way from accounting for crash fault in the CSA Safety Measurement System. In the meantime, questions about the system's effectiveness ...

He also said Bryan misuses CSA’s data. 

Bryan, however, countered Quade’s points by saying his group isn’t in the business of gathering data, and that he’s simply dissecting the data FMCSA itself gathers. “I work for the industry and if I see something truckers need to know, I’m likely to say it,” Bryan said. 

Click here to see Jones’ full story. 

Overdrive ran a months-long in-depth series on CSA’s data and its various problems and disparities — Click here to visit the site dedicated to those stories, which also had downloads to show what violations occur most in what states. 

More About:

, ,


  1. […] A heated debate was sparked last month at the American Trucking Associations Management Conference & Exhibition in Orlando. Steve Bryan, head of Vigillo, went toe to toe with Bill Quade, FMCSA. Both questioned the data collected by the FMCSA. Bryan used the data to ask why most trucking violations occur from BASIC maintenance, rather than traffic violations such as speeding. Quade countered by saying that inspectors who look at a vehicle’s maintenance have training to know exactly what they’re looking for, whereas cops give out traffic violations. He then accused Bryan of misusing the data. For more on the heated debate, you can read the full article here. […]