Channel 19

Todd Dills

Truckers’ proposals "range from useless to harmful"

| April 29, 2008

USA Today on recent trucker fuel-price protests

In an election year, the pressure on Congress to do isomething about energy prices is growing. Proposals are spouting like a Texas gusher. They include giving drivers a summer holiday from the federal gasoline tax, suspending efforts to fill the nation’s Strategic Petroleum Reserve, and forcing shippers to pay truckers a fuel surcharge.

All have superficial appeal. But at a time when the real reasons for high prices are beyond Washington’s control —- static world oil production and rising demand from China, India and other nations —- those ideas range from useless to harmful. …

Truckers are usually fiercely independent and wary of government intervention, but now they want Congress to step in to force shippers to pay them fuel surcharges, or stop middlemen from hoarding the ones shippers pay.

No question, truckers are hurting, but the sort of intervention they seek would prompt pleas for relief for other groups hurt by price increases. The market, not government, has to sort out price disruptions.

The ensuing discussion is interesting and goes on for several pages. One comment is from trucker C.D. Silvernail, who favors drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge

15 years ago Bill Clinton rejected the idea of drilling in ANWR for one reason, that it would take 10 to 15 years until the oil could come to the U.S. markets. Well, it’s 15 years later. Don’t you wish we had started back then? Our politicians’ long-term thinking is only until the next election. strives to maintain an open forum for reader opinions. Click here to read our comment policy.

Stay Connected

Sign up to get Overdrive's daily newsletter.

Todd Dills

Todd Dills is Senior Editor of Overdrive magazine and writes from Nashville, Tenn. He frequently covers business, regulatory and lifestyle topics for the magazine and at His work on the “CSA’s Data Trail” series in Overdrive about the federal CSA program was awarded the highest honor in trade journalism – the “Grand Neal” – by American Business Media at the 2014 Jesse H. Neal Awards. Dills’ Channel 19 blog covers a grab bag of on-highway hearsay, owner-operator news and driver views from the roadways the nation over. His work in trucking journalism builds on a background of news feature, fiction and other creative writing and editing. Find him here at the Channel 19 blog and via his Twitter feed, or send tips to or via phone at 205-907-2481.


View Results