How To: Appeal legal mistreatment

Squelch the impulse to rage at the inspector for rude conduct or at the trooper for an unfair citation. Instead, stick to a professional response and you might end up getting the upper hand. Whether you think you have been unfairly treated or ticketed without breaking a law, the method for filing a complaint is similar in both cases.

On the roadside
· Record the name of the officer who’s writing you up.
If it’s not clear what law or regulation you’re charged with violating, get an explanation.
· Check the citation or ask the officer for the name and phone number of the agency issuing the violation.
· If the infraction does not involve a court appearance, contact the agency to request a hearing. Record the name of anyone you talk to and the date.

Prepare for court
· A complaint or an appeal must be made in the county or city where the incident occurred.
· Confirm by letter or telephone with the municipal or county court the time of your hearing or court date.
· On matters of interpretation regarding Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration regulations or to report a grievance, contact a state FMCSA office, says agency spokesman Duane DeBruyne. State FMCSA contacts are at Click on “About FMCSA,” then click on Field Offices underneath “Contact Us.”
· Gather documents for evidence, such as weight records from a certified CAT scale. If you plan to dispute a charge, hiring an attorney can make a big difference.

In the courtroom
· Arrive looking clean and neat.
· Hearings are often rescheduled, says Jim Klepper of Interstate Truckers legal service. If this happens, decide whether to accept a dismissal or continue the grievance.
· When it’s your time, be respectful and concise. Judges often decide cases in seconds.
· If you’re found guilty, decide if an appeal is worth the expense. From a municipal or county court to a district court, the expense may be affordable, but higher appeals can run $10,000-plus, Klepper says.

Showcase your workhorse
Add a photo of your rig to our Reader Rigs collection to share it with your peers and the world. Tell us the story behind the truck and your business to help build its story.
Submit Your Rig
Reader Rig Submission