Create a free Overdrive account to continue reading

Fuel taxes: Finding the cheapest fuel about more than the pump price

An effective fuel-buying practice is to maximize fuel purchases in low-fuel-tax states and mileage run in those states. The International Fuel Tax Agreement between the United States and Canada facilitates the reporting, collection and distribution of taxes to states and provinces.

You pay taxes every time you fuel, but your ultimate fuel tax bill is calculated according to where you drive. If you purchase fuel in high-tax states and drive most of your miles in lower-tax states, you will get a refund when you file your IFTA report. The opposite -- a tax liability for buying in low-tax states and driving most miles in high-tax jurisdiction -- is also reality.

You cannot reduce your tax outlay unless you choose hauls that avoid high-tax states. What you have more control over is how much you pay strictly for fuel when the fuel tax is not considered.

PUMP PRICE MINUS TAXES = REAL COST. The key to finding the cheapest fuel is to know the current fuel tax rates, both federal and state, and any state surcharges. Subtract taxes to find the raw fuel cost in each state, then buy where fuel is cheapest. The strategy means that you buy without regard for whether you are paying more at the pump -- or in taxes. The 2026-introduced Let's Truck "Driveline Fuel Calc" online tool could be a key cog in the machine for this strategy, showing net real fuel cost on average in every state in the nation at any given time.

Depending on your routes, it might pay fuel-expense dividends even when the pump price appears higher. For instance, after conducting his own analysis, 2025 Trucker of the Year contender owner-operator Scott Smith found fuel stops along a regular route through the high-fuel-tax state of Illinois in fact offered the lowest fuel cost when taxes were removed. He made it a practice of buying there as often as possible, reducing his fuel expense and often enough ensuring an IFTA tax refund after filing. 

IFTA also considers state surcharges, which complicates the fuel-buying strategy. Indiana, Kentucky and Virginia have per-gallon surcharges; Connecticut, Kentucky, New Mexico, New York and Oregon have per-mile surcharges. While some owner-operators buy only enough fuel to get through surcharge states, this practice can backfire, depending on the actual cost of the fuel in each state.

Generally speaking, if you run fairly regular routes, you’ll tend to pay about the same overall total amount of taxes quarter to quarter, given the fees are based on the miles you run and the states in which you run them. If your IFTA mpg (the number of miles you ran in the quarter divided by the number of gallons you purchased in the same time period) is 7 mpg, the average tax per mile may calculate to somewhere between 5 and 8 cents per mile, depending on the states you drive in. The bulk, if not all, required fuel taxes are paid at the pump or other point of purchase.

The Business Manual for Owner-Operators
Overdrive editors and ATBS present the industry’s best manual for prospective and committed owner-operators. You’ll find exceptional depth on many issues in the Partners in Business playbook.
Access the Playbook
Partners in Business Issue Cover