The state of New York has defeated the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration in a key battle that could have major implications for non-domiciled CDLs nationwide.
FMCSA, since the dawn of the second Trump administration, has undergone two rulemaking attempts to ban CDLs for almost all non-citizens.
FMCSA's first nationwide ban in 2025 was thrown out in court, and around the same time the agency issued state-by-state findings of noncompliance forbidding individual states from issuing non-domiciled CDLs.
A second nationwide non-domiciled CDL ban now awaits a court's decision that would either keep or uphold the ban.
California and New York have individually challenged their non-compliance findings, and now New York's victory could be the first step in a march back to CDLs for non-citizens.
[Related: California’s non-domiciled CDL program could roar back to life]
New York defeats FMCSA's non-domiciled CDL ban logic
On Nov. 13, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit decided in favor of New York against FMCSA, finding the agency's decision to hold back $74 million in highway funding from the state "arbitrary and capricious."
FMCSA has called New York the "worst offender" in issuing non-domiciled CDLs incorrectly, but now the Empire State has won a major argument that strikes at the core of FMCSA's national ban.
The core of the argument centers around New York issuing non-domiciled CDLs for a standard term of eight years.
"What New York does is if an applicant comes in [with] work authorization for 30 days, 60 days, one year, New York automatically issues them an 8-year CDL. That’s contrary to the law," said Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, back in December 2025.
FMCSA insisted New York only issue non-domiciled CDLs valid as long as an applicant's legal presence in the country.
"The State must make the period of validity of the non-domiciled CLP or CDL less than or equal to the period of validity of the driver’s lawful presence document(s)," FMCSA wrote in a finding of non-compliance to New York. "Therefore, State driver’s licensing agencies were required to ensure that the validity of non-domiciled CLPs or CDLs did not exceed the expiration date of drivers’ lawful presence documents."
FMCSA further said in 53% of cases audited, New York had issued overlong non-domiciled CDLs among its population of about 32,000 such license holders.
But FMCSA lost the case partly because it did not even attempt to argue that was an existing requirement for issuing non-domiciled CDLs. The court found that New York was within rights to issue CDLs for up to eight years, precisely because an applicant's "legal presence" in the country doesn't really have an expiration date -- often the applicant can extend it.
New York, then, asserted it can issue non-domiciled CDLs for eight years regardless of what term a work authorization specifies, and FMCSA didn't argue with that.
"FMCSA does not attempt a textual argument to the contrary," the court wrote in its decision. "FMCSA conceded in its final determination, throughout its appellate briefing, and at oral argument that the plain text of the regulation does not contain a matching requirement" to match Employee Authorization Document end dates to CDL terms.
Instead of relying on actual legal requirements, the court suggested FMCSA expected New York to essentially read its mind.
Here, the court gets at what could be a significant flaw in FMCSA's non-domiciled crackdown, which could lead not only to New York's further legal victory, but victory for California and non-domiciled CDL holders everywhere.
"FMCSA’s argument rests on the false premise that foreign passports and EADs prove 'the duration of lawful presence,'" the court wrote.
If an applicant's foreign passport expires, their legal presence in the U.S. could also lapse, but often the applicant would simply renew their foreign passport. EADs are often re-issued, too.
"FMCSA does not explain how the expiration date of a passport issued by a foreign country relates to the duration of lawful presence in this country," the court said. "And EADs reflect the duration of work authorization, not lawful presence."
FMCSA can't really compel states to continuously monitor an applicant's legal presence, either, the court found.
"FMCSA does not explain its logical leap from a threshold requirement that an applicant demonstrate lawful presence to an obligation on the part of states to ensure a driver’s continuous lawful presence for the duration of her license," the court wrote.
The court, in its conclusion, ripped FMCSA for relying on "common sense" when the federal regs didn't support its interpretations.
"FMCSA’s attempt to enact an additional expiration-matching requirement out of regulatory silence falls flat," the court wrote. "The agency’s position runs afoul of fair notice principles, departs from the regulatory text, and underestimates the complexity of its supposedly 'common sense' requirement."
How New York's win bodes for the non-domiciled ban final rule
California, where FMCSA also withheld funds as a result of a finding of noncompliance, has a very similar legal challenge to New York's in the works at another federal court, the D.C. appeals court.
That same court is weighing challenges to the FMCSA's final rule halting most non-domiciled CDL issuance across the country.
FMCSA's battle with California dealt with a lot of the same legal and logical challenges as the battle with New York, with DOT's lawyer relying on a more "informal" understanding of how FMCSA works with states and California saying FMCSA had no real legal basis.
In both the California case and the case challenging the FMCSA's rule, the problem of "expiration dates" and legal presence documentation came up time and time again, with judges expressly skeptical of the government's rationale, as in the New York case.
[Related: Is a loophole for visa drivers going to sink FMCSA’s non-domiciled CDL ban?]





















