Bye-bye CSA scores? Another group calls for removal of public carrier rankings

user-gravatar Headshot

crashThe Transportation Intermediaries Association has become the latest organization to call on the DOT to remove from public view the carrier percentile rankings in the Compliance, Safety, Accountability trucking regulatory program, saying it has “serious concerns” about the scores’ methodology and correlation (or lack thereof) to crash risk.

TIA, a trade and lobbying group for brokers and freight forwarders, announced its change in policy this week, joining a growing list of industry groups who officially support removal of the scores until FMCSA can work out the program’s kinks.

The non-partisan government watchdog Government Accountability Office also wants FMCSA to remove the scores from public view. It issued a report last year detailing the program’s faults, saying FMCSA’s data well is too limited and its scores are an unreliable means by which to judge carriers. The program is particularly unfair for small carriers and owner-operators, the GAO said, due to FMCSA’s lack of quality data.

The TIA earlier this year successfully had a bill introduced in the House that aimed to limit CSA’s role in hiring of carriers by brokers and shippers.

But the group’s board of directors this week voted to officially change its position on CSA, now hoping for removal rather than simply relegating its role as an intervention tool for enforcers.

The continued delay by FMCSA in producing a Safety Fitness Determination rule also played a role in the TIA’s change of policy position, the group said.

Nearly 20 other groups who have officially asked FMCSA to remove the scores from public view, including:

  • American Trucking Associations
  • Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association
  • Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance
  • Alliance for Safe, Efficient and Competitive Truck Transportation
  • National Association of Small Trucking Companies
  • Truckload Carriers Association

Several bills have also been introduced in Congress in recent years that would, if passed, require FMCSA to remove the scores until further work is done to shore up the program.

The Business Manual for Owner-Operators
Overdrive editors and ATBS present the industry’s best manual for prospective and committed owner-operators. You’ll find exceptional depth on many issues in the 2022 edition of Partners in Business.
Download
Partners in Business Issue Cover