The U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division Thursday announced a final rule to yet again change the criteria for determining whether workers are employees or independent contractors under the Fair Labor Standards Act and two related federal laws.
The change returns the classification criteria to rules “substantially similar” to those finalized during the first Trump administration in 2021, the department said, rescinding changes made by the Biden administration in 2024.
- DOL said its new rule “provides clarity to businesses and workers alike, as well as the division’s enforcement personnel.”
- An "economic reality" test under the rule's terms uses two “core factors” to help make the determination if a worker is economically dependent on an employer for work or is in business for themselves.
- The factors: nature and degree of control over the work, and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss based on initiative and/or investment.
Consistent with the outcomes of federal appellate cases, DOL noted the final rule provides further guidance on the process for differentiating between employees with protections under the FLSA and individuals who work as independent contractors.
U.S. Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling, Wage and Hour Division Administrator Andrew Rogers, and other department officials hosted an event formally announcing the final rule.
“It’s more important than ever to ensure our labor regulations keep pace with the changing ways that Americans choose to work, and businesses choose to operate,” said Sonderling. “The new Independent Contractor final rule establishes clear, predictable, and easy-to-understand criteria for determining who is an employee and who is an independent contractor."
The final rule applies the department’s streamlined analysis likewise to the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act, both of which use the FLSA’s statutory definition of “employ.”
The rule doesn't change assessment of employee or independent contractor status for the purpose of any other federal laws, including the Internal Revenue Code, and does not preempt any state or local laws.
[Related: Labor Department seeks change to contractor classification regs, again]
How it applies to trucking lease-purchase contractors, among others
For the second economic-reality factor, the opportunity for profit or loss, several trucking associations raised questions during the proposal process about how drivers who lease trucks from motor carriers in lease-purchase agreements should be classified.
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, for example, generally supported the proposed analysis but requested clarification that a lease-purchase agreement is not the type of investment that indicates independent contractor status.
After considering comments from the trucking community, DOL said it “generally believes that the fact that a driver owns a truck and exercises initiative in how to operate it seems to plainly indicate independent contractor status under the opportunity for profit or loss factor.” Yet for drivers who lease trucks from carriers, that factor “seems more nuanced.”
The department provided two examples specific to trucking.
In the first example, a driver leases a truck from and hauls freight for a motor carrier. The company determines the rates that it pays driver for each load, does not negotiate those rates, and assigns loads to the driver without informing him/her of the rates before he/she must commit to the load.
“The driver’s monthly lease payments to the company may theoretically allow him or her to purchase the vehicle one day, but the reality of the economic terms of the lease agreement most likely prevents the worker from ever reaching that point,” DOL said. “Those facts would indicate employee status under the opportunity for profit or loss factor.”
[Related: Carriers' lease-purchase programs 'meaningful' for at least half of lessee operators]
The department’s second example also involved a driver who leases a truck from and hauls freight for a motor carrier. Unlike the first driver, however, this driver’s company offers loads at proposed rates, allowing the driver to negotiate before taking the load. When possible, the driver looks to negotiate a back-haul to avoid driving empty.
“The economic terms of the lease agreement actually provide an opportunity for the worker to own the vehicle in the future,” DOL said of this arrangement, too. “Those facts would indicate independent contractor status under the opportunity for profit or loss factor.”
The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association noted that it'll take some time to fully review the rule, but it did credit DOL for making "several revisions in response to our comments."
"These changes represent a step in the right direction for truckers who seek independence to operate their small businesses," said OOIDA President and CEO Todd Spencer. "While the rule does not address all of our concerns, it also does not create new barriers for an owner-operator to work as an independent contractor."
Spencer added that OOIDA appreciates the clarification "that a carrier can’t micromanage drivers by simply mandating equipment as a 'safety requirement,'" such as speed limiters.
"With that said, the effectiveness of this regulation will be determined by how its details are interpreted and enforced," Spencer concluded. "We look forward to continuing to work with the Department to ensure that these regulations protect the rights of small-business truckers to operate independently, as well as protect drivers from exploitation by carriers.”
The American Trucking Associations said Thursday the new final rule "will rescind a destructive, Biden-era classification standard," adding that its finalization marks "a monumental, hard-fought victory for the hundreds of thousands of truckers who choose to work as independent contractors."
ATA Chief Advocacy & Public Affairs Officer Henry Hanscom added that "many truckers prefer this pathway to entrepreneurship because of the flexibility and freedom it provides, giving them the ability to run their own businesses, set their own hours, and chart their own routes. The Trump Administration’s action replaces a job-killing scheme concocted by special interests with a common-sense framework that protects individual opportunity, our supply chain, and our economy. Trucking is not a one-size-fits-all industry, and Washington bureaucrats had no business dictating how men and women can build their livelihoods and pursue their careers.”
[Related: $2.2M coming to truck drivers after state misclassification suit]
Other factors outside the two core
The rule also IDs other factors to help make an employee/IC determination:
- The amount of skill required for the work
- The degree of permanence of the working relationship
- Whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production
The actual practice of the worker and the potential employer, the rule advises, is more relevant than what may be contractually or theoretically possible.
The department noted “that an individual’s theoretical abilities to negotiate prices or work for competing businesses are less meaningful if, as a practical matter, the individual is prevented from exercising such rights." Similarly, a "business’s contractual authority to supervise or discipline an individual may be of little relevance if in practice the business never exercises such authority.”
The final rule is expected to be published in the Federal Register in the coming days, and will take effect 60 days from that date. Those interested can read the full 388-page final rule here.
[Related: Independent contractor 'regulatory whiplash': Trucking calls for clarity, preservation of option]



















