Overdrive readers delivered a resounding no to the question of whether off-duty driver random drug screens should be allowed.
82% agreed with the aims of truck operator Nathan Weidert's petition to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration to disallow the practice. Regardless of the intent behind the testing rules, given the safety-sensitive nature of work behind the wheel, most commenters described their reasoning for no votes by invoking the sacrosanct nature of off-duty time.
In the words of one: "Because you're off-duty. The company wants a random, then do it on their time, not mine!"
Results above reflect responses from nearly 400 readers, many clearly with experience of off-duty notifications by employing or leasing carriers.
Nathan Weidert's petition to FMCSA suggested conforming the random drug-test guidance to something similar to alcohol testing, which can only be done immediately prior to work, during a shift or immediately after driving. Current random-drug-test rules, rather, require a driver to immediately proceed to a collection site upon notification.
Fleets who are on top of the game for their required annual test quota of 50% of their employed/leased operators, however, have time and discretion about when to notify their drivers.
Third-party test program managers for fleets we've spoken to take a variety of approaches to that, most delivering random selections to fleet personnel on a quarterly basis. Those personnel then notify drivers of randoms with some measure of convenience for the driver in mind, over the course of the ensuing quarter.
One commenter noted 38 years of experience trucking, and echoed that sort of approach by companies he worked for or leased to: "I have never been notified that I was chosen for a random drug test while on time off," the reader said. "I was always notified when reporting for duty or getting ready to go off-duty, and always at a terminal."
That wasn't the case for Nathan Weidert, whose petition was prompted by experiencing a notification from a company he no longer worked for.
Weidert tried to take the test at first. The company sent him to a clinic that was closed, then reported a Refusal to Test in the FMCSA's Clearinghouse for test results. Weidert protested that refusal, and given he was working for a different company at the time of selection notification, FMCSA's since struck the refusal from his Clearinghouse record.
Readers who responded to Overdrive polling detailed some similar experiences, one noting being called up in the midst of painting his house over an off period. Given that a driver must proceed immediately to a collection site on notification, "I had to clean up everything and go pee in a bottle," the reader said.
And go on-duty to boot. Driving to the site, sitting in a waiting room, doing the business, all takes a driver to an on-duty status.
That's put the kibosh on a 34-hour restart well more than once, judging by commenters' experiences. One operator detailed more than one off-duty call-up and refusing to proceed to the collection site immediately to avoid breaking up the restart. "I refuse to go because that puts me in 'on-duty' status," they said. "I need my 34 restart for a reason."
The commenter didn't specify the solution in that case -- waiting for the 34 to complete, presumably -- and didn't wholeheartedly object to past notifications during extended off time at home. More than one reader echoed that sentiment.
A manager of a "pool of owner-operators" noted many would rather be called up to test "while at home than on the road trying to find parking" in an unfamiliar area in a Class 8 rig.
One owner-op had "no problem being notified that I need to do a drug screening off-duty." In his experience, a reasonable amount of time allowed has been the general practice. "When notified while off-duty, the screening should be performed at the driver's convenience, and before resuming safety-sensitive operations (that is, driving)."
While there's no specific time allowance in the regulations describing exactly what immediately proceeding to the collection site really means, that reader suggested a roughly 48-hour timeline had been observed in his experience. Thus, "I think the system in place is still suitable," he said.
[Related: Off-duty randoms, CO detection: Where two driver-led petitions might be headed]
'Immediately': The picture gets murky for testing consortiums, independents
Fleet managers, at least, have a choice in how they approach the notification, according to guidance published at FMCSA's website. For employers the agency's interpretation of what immediately means strives for no gray areas, hence all that paint-work clean-up mentioned earlier:
If an employer selects a driver for a random controlled substances test while the driver is in an off-duty status, and then chooses to notify the driver that he/she has been selected while the driver is still off-duty, the employer must ensure that the driver proceeds immediately to a collection site. Immediately, in this context, means that all the driver’s actions, after notification, lead to an immediate specimen collection. If the employer’s policy or practice is to notify drivers while they are in an off-duty status, the employer should make that policy clear to all drivers so that they are fully informed of their obligation to proceed immediately to a collection site.
If an employer does not want to notify the driver that he/she has been selected for a random controlled substances test while the driver is in an off-duty status, the employer could set aside the driver’s name for notification until the driver returns to work, as long as the driver returns to work before the next selection for random testing is made.
Fleet owners/managers have at least some knowledge of whether a driver is on- or off-duty, and can adjust policy for their operator rosters accordingly, yet independent owner-operators who are part of a drug testing consortium are both owner/employer and driver. In that case, it's next to impossible for a testing consortium to know a driver's current status without direct contact.
Some consortiums approach selection notification with email, and indeed give independent owner-operators a particular amount of time to get the urine bottle full. 48 hours, as was mentioned in reader commentary earlier, is a common threshold, but pegged to the time stamp on when the email was sent, not when it was opened.
Some consortiums expressly note taking into consideration the particular circumstances for each individual driver.
Enforcement happens during compliance reviews/audits, with mixed results, according to one consortium operator we spoke to. It comes down to the investigator, and how strict he/she wants to be about what immediately means.
A different consortium manager who commented on Overdrive's poll felt it was time for FMCSA to clear up gray areas as best they could. The manager was a solid No as to the question of whether off-duty notification should be allowed.
"Off-duty should be prohibited," the manager said of notifications, pointing to how requirements placed on drivers put all involved in untenable situations. "The consortium or employer is in a horrible position if they notify a driver and he or she is out having drinks or out in an area where there’s no available collection site."





















