Channel 19

Todd Dills

‘Legitimate freight options’ — old ways in new times

| November 08, 2016

In addition to Zach Beadle‘s ISS score situation, another reader, Kacie Sill, wrote in over the weekend after reading my update on No Broker Freight published a couple weeks back here on Channel 19. Sill and her husband, she said, were in a somewhat similar situation to the reader noted in the story, Manuel Chavez, trying to suss out “legitimate freight options,” Sill wrote. “We are currently members of TruckersEdge and Truckstop, and are struggling with the rate offers.”


'No Broker Freight' board: Service in limbo until further notice

‘No Broker Freight’ board: Service in limbo until further notice

A reader's difficult experience with the load marketplace concludes; details on steps to take for others in similar situations; and a question: Anybody had success ...

Both of those boards will be familiar to most independents out there. They’re both sources with plentiful freight, most of it from brokers, though some shippers use the technology to source spot capacity from time to time.

Others include 123LoadBoard, Truck It Smart, GetLoaded and more, all with their own monthly subscription prices and spin on things, and all of whom have been around several and more years.

When it comes to the new crop of tech firms and tech-enabled brokerages pitching to operators on the strength of their mobile technology (read: uberization of trucking, again, sort of, those I know plenty of you are sick of the term — me too), the one that might come closest to being “legitimate” in terms of the volume of directly broker-posted loads might be the Trucker Path company’s free Truckloads app.


Trucker Path on a growth spurt toward 'full-blown freight marketplace'

Trucker Path on a growth spurt toward ‘full-blown freight marketplace’

The foundation of Trucker Path's success now and in its future, says company CEO and founder Ivan Tsybaev, "is community. That's what's important. Without that, ...

I talked with company founder Ivan Tsybaev last week in the context of another new player in the mobile-optimized load board or “freight marketplace” space, for lack of a better term. Tsybaev says Truckloads has had success attracting brokers to post freight directly to the Truckloads platform, accessed by owner-operators through the app or via this website, rather than relying on third-party services for loads. “We  have more than 600 companies posting” in Truckloads, he says, to the tune of “100,000 truckloads a day in the platform.”

That follows the company’s introduction of the app in mid-late 2015, following something of a splash with a big presence at the Great American Trucking Show. It’s key to note that what you’ll find in Truckloads is of a piece with other load boards — third party brokers, primarily, as Tsybaev notes. They’re hoping to make their money not through any Truckloads base subscription in the future but via premium accounts with added services in the Trucker Path app itself, likewise a factoring service it’s planning to offer through Truckloads, he adds.

Another marketplace-type service to keep an eye on is Overhaul, which I’ve written about in recent memory. I’ll hopefully talk with them for an update on their progress directly connecting truckers with shippers, not brokers, in the new year at the latest.


'Shippers have a soul' --Overhaul cofounder on pitch to customers for better rates to owner-operators

‘Shippers have a soul’ –Overhaul cofounder on pitch to customers for better rates to owner-operators

In the transportation ecosystem, says Overhaul cofounder Barry Conlon, "the most important guy is the driver," too often getting the short end of the compensation ...

Other such tech companies are operating as brokerages themselves, like Convoy, whose recent announcement of a freight deal with Unilever seemed fairly significant, and one whose recent news sparked the conversation with Tsybaev to begin with, Uber itself, whom a particular Business Insider told me like a little birdie had soft-launched its own freight-matching tech with carrier partners and apparent shipper customers with a full-on launch set for the new year.


Convoy tech-enabled brokerage inks deal with Unilever to handle 'millions' in freight in 2017

Convoy tech-enabled brokerage inks deal with Unilever to handle ‘millions’ in freight in 2017

The Convoy deal with shipper Unilever is victory for a young brokerage operating in something of a nontraditional way, enabled by technology to streamline elements ...

Uber Freight’s brokerage authority is on the books, and its partially-automated driver-assist technology in Otto, which made headlines recently with a partially automated truckload beer delivery in Colorado, has its motor carrier authority with drivers testing its automation technology.

“Otto drivers use Trucker Path too,” Tsybaev says, ribbing his Silicon Valley friends, of a fashion.

Tsybaev (center) with Otto cofounders each wearing the other company's hat.

Tsybaev (center) with Otto cofounders each wearing the other company’s hat.

Which all is to say, a lot is happening, but tried and true methods still are most likely to keep you loaded most profitably long-term. Radio host and well-known owner-operator-business prognosticator (former owner-operator/small fleet owner himself) Kevin Rutherford re-emphasized lane specialization and strong relationships on both ends as a key toward business health for the long term. “We need a lot more collaboration between the owner-operator and the broker,” he said in a panel conversation with Farm2Fleet Trucking’s Bill Hood and’s Brent Hutto at the Connected 2016 user conference last week. Win-lose situations of price-only-type negotiations — many owner-operators’ only contact with their brokers — create very “antagonistic relationships,” Rutherford added. “I’ve been trying to hammer home the idea to the owner-operator that the broker is your customer. [The customer is] always the business that writes the check that you cash.”

He asked the room — mostly brokers — how many felt like the owner-operators they deal with treated them as customers. Nobody raised their hands. Only a couple raised their hands when asked if they treated the owner-operator like a customer. “We need to be working together a whole lot more,” he said.


Kevin Rutherford’s case to brokers for stronger partnerships with owner-operators

Hear how Kevin Rutherford broke the ice with a roomful of brokers: "Many of my listeners think the majority of this room are lying, cheating ...

As I intimated in my Thursday post last week, and which Rutherford repeated in his Wednesday address to the conference, he urged owner-operators and brokers alike to “do the hard work” and build those relationships, taking the time to meet face to face and strengthen ties. “I’ve worked in trucking 30 years, and it’s not unusual for me to start to work with somebody” via a phone conversation, he said. “But when I meet them face to face the relationship changes” for the better.

He urged owner-operators to, “instead of getting on the load boards and chasing rates constantly, pick a couple brokers you like, show up and take them for coffee and lunch – that’d put you in the top 1 percent of owner-operators for them,” more likely to be the go-to biz in the lane where you specialize, the first choice for loads with plenty profit in them.

Provided they’re open to it, of course. A comment under my last post on Rutherford’s advice, from “Nomoredriving”: “Yeah I’m going to make a point to stop by and have a face to face with the hundreds of brokers I’ve used over the years. Sure I got time for that. I’ll bet they all have truck parking at their offices. If they saw a truck pull into the parking lot, they would lock the doors and hide under their desks for fear of retaliation from some driver they hosed. They probably sit behind bulletproof glass and steel doors like so many cowardly dispatchers do.”

And a reply: “At least you have held onto your sense of humor.”

Which all is to say, there’s many ways to skin the cat on freight, of course, and I hope any of this helps, if most is probably well familiar.

What are the rest of you relying on primarily these days? Tips, suggestions, slanders, etc., hit us in the comments below.

Following find links to several more or less in-depth stories on the subject from the past couple years:

Building the shipper customer base for freight

With expected long-term demand for capacity, it’s a good time for independents and small fleets to work toward securing contract freight direct with shippers.

Negotiating rates without needing 'extra blood-pressure medicine'

Negotiating rates without needing ‘extra blood-pressure medicine’

Conceive of negotiations over loads/rates as an opportunity to start or extend a potential long-term business relationship -- don't leave money on the table, but ...

Shipper to owner-operators: Come on down!

Some shippers' common bond with owner-operators -- when it comes to procuring transportation, they'd rather not deal with brokers or large asset-based carriers, either.

'Uberization of Trucking' reality more complicated than the hype

‘Uberization of Trucking’ reality more complicated than the hype

"Uberized'' tech start-ups in load matching may be "missing the complexity of most freight moves and will lose a lot in the translation because of ...

Career advancement for the long haul: One small fleet’s growth story

While a family business is certainly not the only way to start and/or run a small fleet, it is one of the more common; run ...

Cycle analysis: Assessing rate patterns by negotiation day, time of day, quarter and geographical area

Cycle analysis: Assessing rate patterns by negotiation day, time of day, quarter and geographical area

Overdrive’s review of data mined by the load board reveals trends in negotiation timing and lanes. Some could surprise you – and even reward ...

On-demand load matching: Where it’s on the way

Tech startups aimed at long-haul TL need critical mass of freight, carrier capacity and more to compete with systems entrenched in the freight market, ...

There are 2 comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *